One of the major concerns of indigenous residents of our area is that immigrants (and asylum seekers in particular) are unfairly biased when housing is allocated. When I mention to some local people about my job, one of the common complaints I usually hear something about "all of them coming over here and taking up our housing". It’s a serious concern for many people and serves as a source of tension in between the communities.
A recent and detailed study from the Equality and Human Rights Commission shows that that fears of migrants jumping the housing queue are not accurate. Two interesting statistics are as follows:
- 1.8% of social tenants have moved to the UK within the past five years.
- 87.8% were UK-born while 10% were foreigners living in Britain for more than five years.
The report also found that:
Analysis of social housing allocation policies showed now evidence that social housing allocation favours foreign migrants over UK citizens. But there is a small amount of evidence which suggests that they may, unintentionally, discriminate against ethic minority communities who may also have less understanding than white groups, of their housing rights and allocation.
These findings contradict the public perception. However, the perception remains a source of conflict. This leads me to wonder about what is the best way forward... how do we as members of this community, take seriously the fears of the white residents while not pandering to false perceptions? Interestingly, the report suggests that "myth-busting exercises about social housing allocation, conducted by local authorities or other interested parties, are unlikely to change public misconceptions." This could also be applied to the EHRC report itself: detailed research and statistics will not influence people as much as the slogan "British homes for British people".
The greater challenge for us is how do we react to this issue in a distinctly Christian way? How do we speak the truth in love? For those within the church, fears about diversity and change will inevitably exist, but we are informed by the eschatological vision of a "great multitude that no one could count, from every nation, from all tribes and peoples and languages, standing before the throne and before the Lamb" (Rev. 7.9). However, in our mission, this becomes more complicated as the wider community may not share this narrative.
There are no simple answers, and I’m open to suggestions... At the moment, I think it must begin in bringing people into relationship. It also means being bold, creative, and intentional in how we attempt to address false perceptions. Practically, this means coming at the issue and trying to focus on positives through the arts, how immigrants shape and take leadership in our own projects, and fostering a space for relationship that goes beyond mere acquaintanceship to genuine sharing. Of course, the church must embody its witness as an alternative community that transcends racial barriers.